The Best Pizza in Jupiter, FL

Are you a pizza enthusiast seeking the perfect slice in Jupiter, FL? Look no further! I recently embarked on a pizza adventure, exploring some of the top local pizzerias. Here’s a flavorful rundown of the best pizza spots you don’t want to miss:

  1. Benedittis
    Address: 3755 Military Trl, Jupiter, FL
    Hours: Sun-Thur 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Fri-Sat 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

My husband and I recently had the pleasure of dining at this charming local pizzeria, and Benedittis was an absolute delight. From the moment we stepped in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air, setting the stage for a memorable meal. We decided to try both their pizza and hot subs, and we were thoroughly impressed. The pizza was a standout, boasting the perfect balance of flavors and an enticingly chewy crust that we found unique and enjoyable. In fact, it’s safe to say that this place offers the best pizza we’ve tasted in all of Florida. The marinara sauce had a rich and yummy taste that complemented the toppings beautifully. Not to mention, the portions were generous, leaving us feeling fully satisfied.

Moreover, the overall dining experience was exceptional. The service was prompt and friendly, with our orders arriving quickly, thanks to their efficient and courteous delivery team. We were also pleasantly surprised by the freshness and quality of the ingredients used in the dishes. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, making us feel right at home as we relished our meal. Of course, we were so engrossed in enjoying the food that we forgot to snap a picture of the delightful pizza – a true testament to how much we savored the experience. All in all, we can’t wait to return and explore more of their menu; this place has certainly won us over with its incredible food and top-notch service.

However, on one occasion, one customer claimed their crust was undercooked, limp, and too thin.

2. Vinny’s Pizza
Address: 6671 W Indiantown Rd Ste 54 Jupiter, FL 33458
Hours: Mon – CLOSED, Tue-Thur 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Fri-Sat 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM, Sun 12:00 AM – 9:00 PM

We visited Vinny’s Pizza, and it was an absolutely fantastic experience. From the moment I walked in, the lively atmosphere caught my attention – it was bright, clean, and welcoming. Watching the staff expertly craft those beautiful pizzas was surprisingly entertaining. They had a few tables and bar stools, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy a meal. Just a heads up, the front door can be a bit heavy to handle, so come prepared!

The service was impeccable. The staff greeted me warmly, guided me through the menu, and even recommended some local favorites. I ordered a couple of slices and some chicken wings, which were served promptly and were piping hot and wonderfully crispy. The portions were generous – definitely enough for sharing. Plus, they provided paper plates, forks, knives, and napkins for a hassle-free dining experience. The whole meal was a treat, and for the quality and quantity of food, the price was very reasonable.

However, it’s worth noting that not all experiences may mirror mine. Some folks have had less than ideal experiences, citing concerns about the pizza quality and service. Personally, though, I thoroughly enjoyed Vinny’s and will definitely be returning whenever I’m in the area. It’s become my go-to spot for scrumptious local pizza and wings!

3. Carmine’s Coal Fired Pizza
Address: 4575 Military Tr, Jupiter, FL 33458
Hours: Sun-Thur 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM, Fri-Sat 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM

Had the pleasure of dining at this local gem, Carmines, that has become a staple for my friends and me. One of the highlights for us is their fantastic happy hour specials from 3-6pm. Most of the glasses of wine are half-off, and you can grab most appetizers for under $10 during this time. It’s a popular spot, especially during these hours, so we’ve learned to come in early. On sunny days, they even open up the outside bar, adding to the great ambiance.

The menu here is impressively varied, offering something for everyone. We particularly enjoyed their diverse pizza options and the delightful bread with pesto sauce they provide when you arrive. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, and it’s common to see many locals – it truly feels like a neighborhood gem.

During a recent visit, despite being regulars who dine here often, we encountered a hiccup in service. It took an unexpectedly long time to get our pizza, and when it finally arrived, it was cold. Thankfully, the situation was rectified with the help of the manager, but it did leave a slight damper on our otherwise enjoyable evening.

4. Al Forno
Address: 75 E Indiantown Road #701 Jupiter, FL, 33477
Hours: Monday – Sunday 11:00AM – 10:00PM

My recent visit here in Al Forno left me with a delightful experience. The highlight of my meal was undeniably the delicious pizza and calzone. The flavors were just perfect, and I can’t wait to go back for more. The restaurant’s menu is quite extensive, offering a variety of options. During my visit, I ordered a pepperoni pizza, wings, and a chicken parm entree with angel hair pasta. The pepperoni pizza stood out, reminding me of the best northeastern-style pizza with a crispy crust and fresh, high-quality ingredients. The wings were wonderfully crispy, and the chicken parm entree was equally satisfying, especially paired with the addicting marinara sauce. The portions were generous, and the pasta was cooked to perfection.

On the service front, I was impressed by the young lady who answered the phone. She was both professional and pleasant, giving us a heads-up that delivery might take a bit longer on a busy Saturday night. To my surprise, they delivered our order in less time than expected, which was a pleasant surprise. Overall, I’ve had consistently positive experiences here, and the taste and quality of the food make it a place I’ll surely visit again.

However, I have to mention that the restaurant ambiance was a bit of a downside during my visit. The space was small and seemed to get warm quickly, so I decided that getting my meal to go would be a better choice next time.

5. Cucina Pizza
Address: 2525 Military Trail STE 111, Jupiter, FL 33458
Hours: Sun-Thur 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Fri-Sat 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Stepping into Cucina felt like discovering a hidden culinary gem tucked away in Plum Plaza. As a fan of good food and enticing menus, I was immediately impressed by the extensive offerings available. The salad options were particularly abundant, catering to various tastes and preferences. During my visit, I opted for a delightful lunch and treated myself to the Tiramisu for dessert. To say it was superb would be an understatement; each bite was a burst of flavors that left me eager to return for dinner. The restaurant itself exuded a charming ambiance, and the live music playing in the background added a lively touch to the overall dining experience. The service was exceptional, making my time there truly delightful.

Moreover, beyond the delectable food and inviting atmosphere, one aspect that stood out was the impeccable service. The staff at Cucina went above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The attentive and friendly service elevated my visit, making me feel like a valued guest. This, combined with the delicious Tiramisu and the diverse menu, left a lasting impression.

Though, I couldn’t help but notice that the prices, particularly for pasta, were slightly higher than expected for a place located in a strip mall.

6. Lynoras Jupiter
Address: 1548 US-1, Jupiter, FL 33469
Hours: Monday – Friday: 3 pm – 10 pm, Saturday: 11am – 10 pm, Sunday: 11am – 10 pm

My recent visit to Lynoras left me thoroughly impressed and eager for a return visit. From the moment I stepped in, the exceptional service stood out – the staff was attentive, friendly, and really enhanced our dining experience. The highlight of the day was the delightful food – the hot honey pizza was a personal favorite, but my husband and daughter were equally taken by the flavors of the white pepperoni pizza and the “Nutella sandwich” (Nutella stuffed French toast). The homely atmosphere made the entire dining experience feel warm and inviting, setting it apart from other locations we’ve been to.

I would suggest making a reservation in advance, as the place can get busy and waiting times can be longer than expected. Despite this, once seated, the delicious homemade noodles and impeccable main courses like the chicken piccata and breaded beef truly stole the show. The delightful taste and quality of the bread added to the overall delightful experience. On the downside, the dessert was a letdown, and the prices seemed slightly high for certain menu items. Nevertheless, the overall visit was fabulous

7. Casa Mia
Address: 337 E Indiantown Rd Suite E10, Jupiter, FL 33477
Hours: Sun-Thur 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM, Fri-Sat 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM

My recent visit to Casa Mia was a delightful Italian culinary journey. The diverse menu offered an array of Italian delights, and I couldn’t resist trying the pastas, pizza, eggplant, and calamari. The flavors were on point, and the Tiramisu, although wonderful, could have used a touch more coffee to truly hit the mark.

Stepping into Casa Mia was a warm experience; the ambiance was inviting, and the staff were notably friendly and accommodating. As I sat down, a basket of warm, fresh bread with a rich oil and garlic spread appeared—a promising start. The appetizers, especially the Frito Misto, were crispy and perfectly cooked, setting the tone for the evening. The Pappardelle with a Wild Boar Ragout was a standout, with rich, flavorful sauce and perfectly cooked pasta. The broad wine selection, including excellent options by the glass, added to the overall enjoyment.

However, there were a few aspects that could be improved. There seemed to be some inconsistencies in dish quality, and some of the dishes, particularly the chicken saltimbocca, didn’t align with traditional expectations.

In conclusion, Jupiter, FL boasts a variety of pizzerias, each with its own unique charm and flavors. Whether you’re a pizza purist or seeking diverse options, these spots promise a tasty adventure!

Recent News

Need help? Click here for help in using our site!

Newsletter Subscription

Get the latest news from Jupiter Daily regarding local events and grand openings. Our newsletter also provides you with printable coupons delivered right to your email box! Your email information is used only for the purpose of receiving our newsletter and we will not share your information with anyone. Unsubscribe anytime easily by clicking the link provided in the Newsletter or by returning to this page.

Please fill out the form below to subscribe to our newsletter.