The dining room and bar at Rusty Hook Tavern in Juno Beach

A Water Leak Closed Rusty Hook for a Month. Juno Beach Helped Bring It Back.

On October 13, a water leak from a neighboring unit at Plaza La Mer forced Rusty Hook Tavern to close its doors. For owners Todd and Danielle Underwood, that meant a month with the dining room dark and the bills still arriving, the kind of stretch that sinks small family restaurants through no fault of their own.

Juno Beach decided that was not how this story ends. Regulars and neighbors chipped in contributions to help the Underwoods cover their bills while the tavern sat closed, and the Kind Diners Society, a local group that surprises independent restaurants with gifts of kindness, added a $600 check of its own, presented to Todd and Danielle in person. In the Jupiter and Palm Beach Gardens food groups this week, the family’s thank-you post drew a wave of replies from people promising to come in and eat, which is exactly the kind of support that spends even better than a donation.

The tavern reopened on Tuesday, November 10, at 11 a.m., and the kitchen has been back at it since: fresh seafood, burgers and wings, and the plates regulars order on repeat, like the Tacos Ahoy with mahi or shrimp, the Sailor’s Mahi Delight, and the Captain’s Crunchy Grouper Sandwich. The Rusty Hook sits at 805 Donald Ross Rd. in Plaza La Mer, next to the Dunkin’ at the corner of Donald Ross and U.S. 1, in the space longtime locals may remember as the Garden City Cafe. It is family-owned in the literal sense, and the room feels it: local art on the walls, a granite bar, and breakfast on the weekends.

Now the Underwoods want to return the favor. This Thursday, November 19, the tavern is hosting a thank-you night for the neighborhood that carried it through the closure, with complimentary light bites from 6 to 8 p.m. and a standing invitation for neighbors who have never been in to come meet the family. No program, no pitch, just food on the house for two hours.

A month ago this was a story about a leak. It turned into a story about what a neighborhood does when one of its own places is in trouble. Thursday night is the receipt.

If you go: Rusty Hook Tavern, 805 Donald Ross Rd., Plaza La Mer, Juno Beach. Thank-you night Thursday, Nov. 19, complimentary light bites 6 to 8 p.m. Regular hours: Wednesday to Friday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., Saturday 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., Sunday 8 a.m. to 2 p.m., Monday 11 a.m. to 3 p.m., closed Tuesdays. Call 561-624-7944, or visit rustyhooktavern.com.

Reporting note: Closure, reopening and community-support details are from the Kind Diners Society’s November newsletter and the Underwood family’s public posts, checked Nov 18, 2026. Hours are from the tavern’s public listings. The thank-you night details are from the family’s post in the Jupiter/PBG Foodies group.

Newsletter Subscription

Get the latest news from Jupiter Daily regarding local events and grand openings. Our newsletter also provides you with printable coupons delivered right to your email box! Your email information is used only for the purpose of receiving our newsletter and we will not share your information with anyone. Unsubscribe anytime easily by clicking the link provided in the Newsletter or by returning to this page.

Please fill out the form below to subscribe to our newsletter.

Subscription Form Popup