A proposal to allow up to 15 homes per acre on big Beach Road properties, written for one developer's project, deadlocked the Planning and Zoning Board on Thursday. The Village Council gets the final say starting December 10.
Tequesta's most contested development idea in years now heads to the Village Council with no clear signal from the board that reviewed it first.
On Thursday night, the Planning and Zoning Board took up a pair of ordinances that would create a density bonus program for the Village's R-3 multi-family district. Under the program, a property of five acres or more could build at up to 15 homes per acre instead of the current 12, if the Village Council decides the project offers enough public benefit in return. The ordinances were written at the request of the developers behind 250 and 300 Beach Road, who want to fit more, smaller condos on their combined site.
The board split down the middle. On Ordinance 17-26, the amendment to the Village's Comprehensive Plan that would authorize the program, a motion to recommend approval never received a second. A motion to recommend denial was seconded and then tied 2-2, and the chair said the tie would be forwarded to the Council as-is. On Ordinance 18-26, the zoning code that would run the program, the board voted 3-1 to recommend approval, with a suggestion from the board that the program be limited to oceanfront properties. That limit is not in the ordinance as written, and the Council is free to ignore it. Village staff had recommended approving the program as drafted.
Only four board members voted on the items, and the evening included a procedural dispute: an alternate member argued on the record that she had been improperly kept from voting on them.
How the bonus would work
The base rules would not change. R-3 properties would still be allowed 12 homes per acre as a general matter, and height, setback and open-space standards stay exactly as they are. The extra three units per acre would be available only to properties of at least five gross acres with a Medium Density Residential land use designation. Contiguous parcels under the same ownership could be combined to reach five acres; parcels across a street from each other could not.
The bonus is explicitly not an entitlement. A developer would apply alongside a site plan, and the Council could approve it, attach conditions, or turn it down. In exchange for the added density, the developer would have to provide public benefits that are significant, go beyond what the Village Code already requires, and be spelled out in measurable, enforceable terms. The list of qualifying benefits in the draft ordinance includes undergrounding utility lines, improving public beach access, streetscape and right-of-way work, dune restoration and coastal resiliency projects, stormwater and infrastructure upgrades, public parking, parks, public art, and bicycle and pedestrian improvements.
One thing the program does not require is affordable or workforce housing. The developers cited other South Florida cities that trade extra density for workforce units, but the Tequesta draft ties the bonus to public benefits only.
The project behind it
The ordinances exist because of one site. The applicants, 250 Beach Road Developer LLC and 300 Beach Road Developer LLC, are preparing a project called Atlantic Beach Residences on their combined Beach Road property, which their development team described at the hearing as 5.42 gross acres. With the bonus, they say, the project would go from 65 homes to 80, in buildings no taller or bulkier than what is allowed today; the additional homes come from making the units smaller, averaging about 1,000 square feet, with more two-bedroom layouts.
The public benefits offered for that project include burying the FPL overhead power lines along Beach Road, a process the developer says is already started with FPL, plus a new beach pathway, an outdoor shower, benches and an overlook. Staff's traffic analysis put the larger version at up to 357 vehicle trips a day from the 250 Beach Road property, about 58 more than the base project.
A neighboring resident disputed the foundation of the whole request, arguing that roughly a quarter of the site lies in the Atlantic Ocean on state-owned land, which would leave about four buildable acres, under the program's five-acre threshold. That question was raised at the hearing and not resolved.
In practice, the program's reach in Tequesta would be tiny. Staff told the board that besides the Beach Road site, the only other property that could realistically qualify is the Seamist and Island House South condominiums combined, a little over five acres, which could go from 66 homes to 82 under a future redevelopment. Between the two, staff estimated the program could add about 31 homes along the Beach Road corridor.
The opposition
The strongest objection on file comes from across the water. The Town of Jupiter Inlet Colony, in a letter signed by Town Manager Heidi Siegel, told the Village its Town Commission unanimously opposes the ordinances, citing traffic, emergency access and response times over Cato's Bridge, the island's only way in and out, along with overdevelopment and coastal erosion and flooding concerns. Siegel also spoke against the proposal at Thursday's hearing. The developers countered that most Beach Road buildings support the project, a claim other speakers disputed.
What happens next
Both ordinances go to the Village Council for a first reading on December 10, with a public hearing and second reading scheduled for January 14. Even if the Council adopts them, the Comprehensive Plan amendment still needs a state review, roughly 30 days, before it takes effect, and no density bonus can be granted until it does. The Atlantic Beach Residences site plan itself has not been filed yet.
Thursday's split board means the Council takes up the idea without a recommendation it can lean on, in a room that will likely hear the same arguments again, louder.