It started, as so many Jupiter food emergencies do, with a Facebook post. “I waited too long to get a pie from Upper Crust,” a neighbor wrote in the Jupiter locals unfiltered group this week. “Who has the best apple pie LOCALLY and DO NOT say Publix!”
The Upper Crust, the family-owned Lake Worth bakery that has been turning out deep-dish pies for more than 45 years, inspires that kind of loyalty, more than 30 varieties of it. The good news from the thread, and it checks out: you do not have to drive to Lake Worth, and you may not be too late. Two shops close to Jupiter carry the very same Upper Crust pies, and both are still taking Thanksgiving orders as of this weekend.
TerMarsch Groves, Juno Beach. The county’s last citrus stand, family-run since 1959, stocks Upper Crust pies year-round at 13900 U.S. Highway 1, and it posted its Thanksgiving pie list this week: Washington Apple, Dutch Apple Crumb, American Pumpkin and Southern Pecan on the fruit side, plus cream pies from Dutch Chocolate to Key Lime. Call 561-626-1177 to order, and do not wait for a second reminder, because that is how this whole story started.
Antonio’s Italian Market, North Palm Beach. The family-owned Italian market and deli at 12214 U.S. Highway 1 carries a rotating selection of 30-plus Upper Crust flavors at $21.99 each, apple included, and is taking holiday pre-orders now at 561-625-6544. Their own warning is worth repeating: Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter sell out fast.
The wild card: Gina’s Cheesecakes & More, Palm Beach Gardens. If your table can bend from pie to cheesecake, one commenter pointed to Gina’s, a home bakery that sells from a self-serve honor fridge at 6017 Edgemere Court, open daily 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Her Thanksgiving order deadline was Friday, but she posted that the fridge stays stocked ahead of the holiday week, first come, first served, and 10 percent of proceeds benefit Emma’s Place, which supports children with special needs and their families.
One practical note before you drive anywhere: selections rotate and everything moves quickly this week, so call ahead and ask what is actually on the shelf. And if your heart is set on a specific Upper Crust flavor, order it today. The original poster is what happens when you wait.
Reporting note: The recommendations came from a Nov 19, 2026 thread in the Jupiter locals unfiltered group (15 comments). Carrying and ordering details were checked Nov 21, 2026 against TerMarsch Groves’ own Thanksgiving posts (Nov 10 and 17) and Antonio’s Italian Market’s Upper Crust page. Gina’s details are from her Nov 20, 2026 post.